I have used both types of power feeds. The gear box style is reliable but not easy to change the gears. Quiet as it gets.
I used a Servo too. The old power feed shaft connects to the mill X screw by locating in a ho;e in the end of the screw's shaft. At the connection
there is a hole with a metal pin. I would replace the metal pin with a cotter pin. A Servo or similar feed would have an adapter.
My power feed sheared the pin and damaged the sleeve that holds the bearings and gears on the screw shaft. I have not been able to find that piece for replacement, the rest of the power feed runs and works fine.
The screw for this setup is longer than other screws.
I have one of the cheap import servo style power feeds that I dont think will work because the screw is longer. I am trying to find out if my options of
A.) Is there an adapter that can make the import servo work with my current screw?
Or
B.) Do I need a different screw for the import servo feed?
Or
C.) Does anyone know of a source of the original part that was damaged so I can just use the original gear power feed that still works fine?
Thanks for all your help so far,
John